Packer Chapter 1

·

On Our Knees We Are All Calvinists? Packer’s Argument from Prayer

Filed under

A copy of J. I. Packer’s Evangelism and the Sovereignty of God arrived in the post around September, sent by a brother I respect, with a note: “Worth another read.” I first read it about seven years ago. I have now read it again, slowly, and I intend to go through it here one chapter at a time, because the book is short, it is well written, and it is very likely the most persuasive popular defence of Reformed theology in print. If it fails, it is worth knowing exactly where.

Chapter 1 is only a few pages long, and it does not open a single disputed text. It does something cleverer. It tells you that you already agree with the Reformed position. Allegedly.

What Packer says

Packer’s claim is that every Christian believes in the sovereignty of God in salvation, whatever he may say when he argues about it, and that the proof is in how he prays (ch. 1, “Divine Sovereignty”). He offers two pieces of evidence, and I will set them out as fairly as I can:

  1. You thank God for your conversion. You do not congratulate yourself, and you would not dream of sharing out the credit between God and you.
  2. You pray for the conversion of others. You ask God to save them, which you would not do unless you believed He is able to bring it about.

The conclusion Packer draws is that you already hold, in your heart, that God is entirely responsible for the salvation of sinners. The old quarrel between the Calvinist and the Arminian is therefore a quarrel between the head and the knees; when we pray, we all confess the same thing.

It is a very attractive argument. It asks for no Greek, no church history and no proof texts, only that you look honestly at your own prayers.

Does it follow?

Fair enough; I do both. I thank God for saving me, and I pray for people I love who do not yet believe. Both premises are true of me, and I grant them without reservation.

But notice what has just happened. From the fact that I give God all the credit, I am supposed to conclude that I contributed nothing at all, not even the believing. Does that follow?

A man pulled out of the sea thanks the lifeboat crew. He does not thank himself for grabbing the rope, and he would be a fool to divide the honours: so much to the coxswain, so much to my own right hand. Yet nobody concludes from his gratitude that he was unconscious throughout. He gives the crew all the credit because they did everything that made the rescue possible, and because without them his grabbing would have been grabbing at water.

The word doing the work in Packer’s argument is “credit”, and it is being used in two senses. In the first premise it means merit: who deserves the thanks? In the conclusion it means agency: who performed every act involved, including the act of believing? The first is a question about honour, the second about mechanics. I can answer “God alone” to the first without having said a word about the second.

Paul keeps them apart himself. Faith, he says, is precisely the thing that is not a work and earns nothing: “to the one who does not work, but believes on Him who declares the ungodly to be righteous, his faith is credited for righteousness” (Romans 4:5). The believer has believed, and has nothing to boast of. Both are true at once, and Paul sees no difficulty in it.

Wesley prayed the same prayers

And here is the problem for Packer. Charles Wesley wrote “And Can It Be” within weeks of his conversion in 1738, and there is not a line in it that takes any credit for anything. His brother John preached Free Grace the following year, the sermon that calls unconditional election a doctrine full of blasphemy. The same household, the same year, the same knees.

Packer knows this; it is the very point he is making. Arminians thank God for their conversion and pray for the lost exactly as Calvinists do. But follow that through. Suppose the prayer really does prove what Packer says it proves. Then we are left with two options:

  1. The Wesleys did not mean their prayers; or
  2. The Wesleys were Calvinists on their knees and Arminians at their desks, and never once noticed in fifty years.

The first is slander and the second is absurd. There is a third option, and it is much simpler: the prayer does not mean what Packer says it means. If the Arminian and the Calvinist are indistinguishable when they pray, then the prayer cannot tell us which of them is right; it simply cannot. A test that both sides pass is no test at all.

So the argument that was meant to settle the debate before it starts turns out to be the one piece of evidence that is, by Packer’s own account, common to both parties.

What am I praying for, then?

First, though, a sentence of Packer’s that is stated as plain fact: “the recognition of God’s sovereignty is the basis of your prayers”. Is it? Sovereignty means ultimate authority; the sovereign is the one above whom there is no other. That is true of God, and it is not why I pray to Him. Nobody brings his troubles to an authority simply because it is the highest one. I pray because the One who holds that authority is my Father: trustworthy, loving, almighty and just. Jesus did not teach us to begin “Our Sovereign”. He taught us to say “Our Father” (Matthew 6:9), and He had just given the reason: “your Father knows the things you need before you ask Him” (Matthew 6:8).

Someone will say: very well, but when you pray for an unbeliever, what exactly are you asking God to do, if not to regenerate him?

It is a good question, and Scripture answers it. I am asking God to do the things He is shown doing.

I am asking the Spirit to do what Jesus said He would do: “He will convict the world about sin, righteousness, and judgment” (John 16:8). Notice the object. It is the world, not the elect; and it is conviction, not regeneration. Conviction is by its nature something a man can yield to or fight, which is why Stephen can say to the council, “You are always resisting the Holy Spirit” (Acts 7:51).

I am asking God to arrange that the person hears, as He sent Philip down a desert road to one man in a chariot (Acts 8:26-29) and Peter to the house of Cornelius (Acts 10).

I am asking Him to gain the person’s attention, as with Lydia: “The Lord opened her heart to pay attention to what was spoken by Paul” (Acts 16:14). This verse is often quoted for the other side, so read it carefully. Lydia was already a worshipper of God before Paul arrived. And what the Lord opened her heart to do was pay attention (προσέχειν). The believing is hers.

Every one of these is a real act of God upon a real person, and I could not ask for any of them if God were not able to act in the world. None of them is a unilateral new birth performed on someone who has not believed. Prayer for the lost presupposes a God who acts; it does not presuppose a God who decides for them.

“And this is not from yourselves”

The text that stands behind the whole chapter is this one:

For you are saved by grace through faith, and this is not from yourselves; it is God’s gift—not from works, so that no one can boast. (Ephesians 2:8-9)

It is usually read as if “this” pointed back to “faith”, so that faith itself is the gift and the believer contributes nothing, not even his believing. The Greek will not allow it. “This” (τοῦτο) is neuter; “faith” (πίστις) is feminine, and so is “grace” (χάρις). The pronoun cannot be pointing at either noun. It points at the whole affair: being saved, by grace, through faith. This is not from yourselves; this is God’s gift.

I am not the first to say so. Calvin says the same in his commentary on the verse: Paul does not mean that faith is the gift of God, but that salvation is given to us by God. When Calvin and I agree on the grammar, the grammar is probably safe.

And look at the contrast Paul actually draws. It is not “God’s act” against “man’s act”. It is grace against works, and faith stands on the side of grace: “the promise is by faith, so that it may be according to grace” (Romans 4:16). Faith is the one response that takes no credit, because all it does is receive.

Why it matters

Why spend this long on a chapter of a few pages? Because of what the chapter is for. It is there so that, by the time you reach the texts in chapter 2, you believe the question is already closed and that your own prayers closed it. Everything after that is read as the working out of something you have conceded.

You have conceded nothing of the kind. To thank God for your salvation is to say that He deserves the thanks. To pray for the lost is to say that He is able and willing to act. To do both is to be a Christian, of any school or none. It is not to sign a system.

So keep thanking Him, and do not let anyone tell you that your gratitude commits you to a decree. The man who believes has done the one thing that leaves him with nothing to show for himself, and Scripture said so long before Packer did:

Where then is boasting? It is excluded. By what kind of law? By one of works? No, on the contrary, by a law of faith. (Romans 3:27)

Next: chapter 2, and the “antinomy”.

Notes

  • J. I. Packer, Evangelism and the Sovereignty of God (London: Inter-Varsity Press, 1961), ch. 1, “Divine Sovereignty”. Packer’s argument is paraphrased throughout; page references to be added from the printed copy.
  • Charles Wesley, “And Can It Be”, written 1738, first published in Hymns and Sacred Poems (1739).
  • John Wesley, Free Grace (Bristol, 1739).
  • John Calvin on Ephesians 2:8, in Commentaries on the Epistles of Paul to the Galatians and Ephesians.
  • Scripture quotations are from the Holman Christian Standard Bible (HCSB).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The occasional letter

Stay in the loop.

Ministry updates, new writing, and published translations—sent thoughtfully, never noisily.